TRANSCRIPT
00:00:02
Good evening. Welcome. [applause] Welcome to our first Long Now talk of the year with Indie Johar. We're so thrilled. I'm Rebecca Lendel, executive director here at the Long Now Foundation. Um, I want to open with a thought Indie shared with us last night that really stayed with me. He reminded us that every industrial revolution in history has been co-joined by a learning revolution. And I think one of the reasons it stayed with me is because a learning revolution is a big part of what Long Now is all about. We're here
00:00:41
to foster more adaptive, more complex, more expansive thinking. Uh especially as we move through the revolution of our times. So, if a learning revolution sounds good to you, for times like these, we invite you to get connected to Long Now, to each other, to a whole world of long-term thinking. We hope you'll consider becoming a supporting member and returning again and again to learn with us. Um, if you're a current member, either here in the room or joining on the live stream, thank you so
00:01:12
much. You make so much of what we do possible. And a huge thanks to our incredible staff, board, council members, supporters. You make everything we do possible. Thank you. Big round of applause. [applause] Um, in a moment I'll invite up our host for this evening, Long Now's Director of Strategic Initiatives, Denise Hearn, who gave her own fantastic Long Now talk a few years back on embodied economics. Uh, Denise will introduce Indie and then um lead a lively discussion following the talk. Um,
00:01:50
after Denise's intro, uh, we'll begin with a short film on long-term thinking. It's a tradition here we call our long short that helps us all kind of drop into the evening's program. Tonight's long short is called Machine Learning by Luke White. And that's it. Thank you all for being here. And uh, over to Denise. [applause] Hi everyone. It is wonderful to be with you. Um I'm so excited to be hosting Indie for his talk tonight. We've known each other for a number of years. In
00:02:24
fact, uh I had just started my embodied economics fledgling newsletter. Uh probably with one subscriber and I was enamored with Indy's work and I asked if I could interview him for my newsletter and the generous person that he is, he said yes. Uh and so it feels very fun all these years later to now be in conversation together with all of you. uh Indie is a true provocator of better institutional and infrastructural futures and I think at a time when our institutions feel like they're crumbling, when it feels like options
00:02:57
for the future are actively foreclosing all around us, what I find incredibly inspiring about Indy's work is that he offers hopeful provocations about how we may rethink, rebuild, redesign the fundamental dark matter of our systems, our institutions and our primary logics. So Indie uh is co-founder of Dark Matter Labs and it's described as a living lab for building options for the next economies. He's also an award-winning architect and urban designer. And he has many affiliations and projects, but some
00:03:36
of them include the London Interdisciplinary School, Open Systems Lab, Bloxs Hub, our MIT University, and many more. So, we're thrilled to have Indie joining us tonight for his talk, but also as a new member of our recently launched advisory body called the council at Long Now. So, we will Yes. and we have I think a few council members here as well tonight. So, thank you for being here. Uh and we're thrilled to have his genius in forming the future of Long Now as an institution. So, uh you're in for a
00:04:08
treat tonight and enjoy the long short. We'll be back with more. >> [music] [music] [music] [music] >> How do I do? [music] >> [music] >> Wow. Wow. I love [snorts] [music] you. [music] >> [music] >> Good evening. [applause] Um, it's an absolute honor to be here. Um, I'm not a person that's ever built kind of dream goals of being in certain situations, but I have to say, um, I want to just start with a thank you. I've never dreamt of being here in a
00:06:41
landscape of that was built by people like Kevin and Stephen and many other brilliant people who I admired from a distance and to be sitting in front so many of you is an absolute honor. So I want to start with a thank you. Um I want to give you a frame of this talk. I so long now does amazing talks and with some brilliant people. I think Sarah Walker's talk here was extraordinary and I had the pleasure to listen to it multiple times. Um I'm not going to I I think there are many talks that give
00:07:17
you an idea an idea of seeing the world differently. I want to talk a little bit about a different strategy of seeing in the world um and a different object of action of how we could make change in the world that we see around us and why it's necessary. This is going to be a bit of a long arc. So, I'm going to invite you on a little bit of a journey uh with me on that arc. So, be patient with me. So, one of the reasons I'm delighted and honored to be here is that I think this is an important moment to talk about
00:07:50
what is a long now view in a world which is increasingly becoming foreshortened and our futures become increasingly opaque and unforeseen and unimaginable. I think how we talk about along now becomes actually increasingly critical. And it's also worth recognizing why that is. And I I would like to put forth to you that I think we're living in a moment of systemic degenerative volatility. Now, this volatility is rooted in multiple factors and I'm going to name some drivers. One of them inevitably
00:08:27
right now is that we're heading in many ways towards climate breakdown. Note I'm not using the word climate change. I'm talking about climate breakdown which is the breakdown of predictable weather weather patterns to which we've been used to. And that landscape is between 2.8 to 3.1 degrees is likely the projected scenario of the world that we're living in. Those numbers become very easy. Now 3 degrees 1.5 3 degrees. What does 3 degrees global average mean? It means five degrees on land it means 8 degrees
00:09:02
warmer in your urban environments. Now even those are just numbers. But when you put those numbers into factor that between 1.7 to 1.9° we will almost certainly lose one of the major food baskets of the world. There are five major food baskets. So that's between 1.7 to 1.9 degrees. Now why that's important is actually the impact that has around the world in ways that I think are non-predictable and I'll talk a little bit more about them. So on one hand and remember I'm using temperature
00:09:33
as just a proxy. It's actually climate volatility in every sense that we're starting to see am currents. You've already just seen some of the stuff that's happened around Chicago. We are seeing volatility in our weather weather systems. And for the UK, for example, that means most likely what used to be a kind of 10% chance of occurring, but likely now is a significant effect is the AOK current effectively becoming weakened to the point that we lose the AOK current as a stabilizing framework for the UK and
00:10:05
Northern Europe. So, Northern Europe looks a lot more like Montreal. No disrespect to Montreal, lovely city, but you know, minus minus 20 plus 40 is a bit extreme. So we start to see these kind of catastrophic moments that start to become visible. The one thing I'm going to put into your minds is that we often talk about these end states. People talk about 3 degrees. People talk about minus 20 plus 40. But actually the more damaging issue is the volatility that happens between now and the end
00:10:36
point. So it's not the new stabilization positions. It's the volatility that happens. So as we break lose the amark current there's about predicted in some of the models is about a 10year wind window of systematic large scale volatility. Why is that volatility important? Because that volatility has whiplash effects in terms of actually whether it's price inequality all sorts of effects. That is the period that is actually far more destabilizing. The end goal we might be able to deal with or
00:11:05
may not be able to deal with but the volat volatility period happens first. Second, ecological breakdown. Well, it sounds a bit dramatic, but the UK government is pretty much just released in the last two weeks one of the most interesting reports out there looking at the catastrophic effects with ecological breakdown, its relationship to social contract. Why? I think keep your eyes on this. I think why this is important. Often we talk about the ecological biohysical effects, but I think what we
00:11:36
need to keep an eye on is the relationship of those ecological effects to social contract loss. And as you lose that, you start to lose pretty much most of our assets and theories of value in society in multiple ways. Third, we're also living in a moment of certainly born in this close to here in a kind of an idea of a new form of general purpose technology which can create a hedgemony of power for the next 50 years which is creating a form of race of resources and compute and futures that is also creating a sense of
00:12:14
existential competition to the point that we've never never had before because of the fear it generates of a runaway power structure and a hedgemony that if it's not here, it's somewhere else. And this means in real people's lives, not just the kind of conceptual problems, but the practical problems of food prices, energy prices. Highly nutritious good foods in the UK have gone up 82%. 82% in the last two years. So, we're seeing a systematic inequality start to drive into the into the into the
00:12:50
environment. These are UK stats. So as we look forward into this, what you start to see is an environment that's becoming systemically fragile, volatile, fracturing into it ge geopolitical competition and also weaponizable. And why I bring this up is that we often talk about existential risks and existential pathways uh as meteorites and other frameworks. I want to put forward to you is that we're living in a moment when these risks are actually cascading into becoming existential because they're falling into cascades.
00:13:30
The cascades whether it's heat cascades and other effects. One of the major cascades, if you look, if you remember 2008, some of you will remember this, 2008, there were fires around Moscow, which meant that Russia stopped the export of fertilizers. As a result, what you saw were food prices around the world go through the roof. And those food prices meant there were riots in 60 cities around the world. And the Arab Spring was almost certainly catalyzed by those situations. So you get a relationship between
00:14:04
fertilizer, fires, fertilizer all the way through social contract. And when you start to look at those cascades in more and more significant ter terms, you start to open yourself up to these pathways where we cannot stabilize a social contract. These force couplings, we're being coupled around the world in different ways. what looked like divisible environments start to become planetarily coupled. And in that moment, we reach for what I would call New Zealand strategies. And you know, there were moments when pe
00:14:44
when people with significant wealth thought that you could actually go backwards and hide in New Zealand. But it very quickly becomes very apparent that it's very difficult. New Zealand didn't have access to antibiotics, didn't have access to microchip production, didn't have access to PPP. So what you found in COVID was that actually to live outside the planetary context becomes increasingly difficult. Some of you may Denise was in pre-con conversations was pointing out the difficulty of even making a toaster,
00:15:18
right? Forget a microchip, a toaster. And you've probably all seen the kind of like um I think it was Milton Freeman's thing with the pencil, right? So we live in this kind of delusional conversation about forced decoupling and our capacity to decouple from the planet. And whether I talk about the toaster or whether I talk about the pencil or even a rainforest, you can't decouple a rainforest from the planet because the rainforest is fundamentally charging and transforming the atmospheric rivers that
00:15:54
are operating across the planet. And that opens up a question about what is our strategy of operating in a planetary context. But as we start to see this volatility, there's a kind of Substack post I wrote about the kind of killline economy. We're also seeing people becoming increasingly fragile, increasingly vulnerable in ways and the future is becoming forcehortened. The capacity to perceive into the future is becoming increasingly difficult. And that is not just a function of uh intellectual
00:16:31
capacity or anything like that. It's a question that if you are, you know, if I'm hungry today, climate change and breakdown does not matter tomorrow or in 30 years time because I'm hungry today. So if you want to fracture a society's capacity to be able to perceive the future in a shared social contract, what you have to do is create differential risks. My risk today is hunger today. Well, I don't give a about climate breakdown because I'm going to be dead in seven days if I don't have food.
00:17:02
Right? If I have if I have only a monthly paycheck, what's the average savings? I think in the US it's less than a month and a half, I think. So that means that we have systematically economically foreshortened society's capacity to perceive the future. And that's making our capacity to imagine a long future systemically fragile. And we cannot create consensus or legitimacy around those frameworks. So in partial ways we feel privileged but the privilege is a function of this breakdown.
00:17:40
And this opens up for me one of the most important questions. What are we trying to preserve here? I'm going to be a little bit difficult but only as a friend. Often when I get into these rooms and the question of preservation, there's a very reductive conversation about the what we're trying to preserve, which is the minimal viable continuity of civilization. Right? Long-termism, the thesis of long-termism, you could argue if you was difficult, is about preserving the minimal viability of continuity of
00:18:17
civilization. that is not preserving 8.5 billion people. There is an instant discount in that concept which I think has not only horrific imaginary possibilities to it but also legitimizes a pathway to think that way. I want to offer you a different idea and it builds on a different way of looking at the continuity of civilization. James Love Log's sec last book on Novacene I think is a beautiful book. The first third of it is extraordinary and the way he narrates our moment I think sets up sets us up for a different
00:19:02
idea of continuity. So I'm going to paraphrase and I'm sure he'll forgive me. Um if you look he would argue that the earth stored vast amounts of solar energy in hydrocarbons and it released that energy in the formation of an 8.5 billion civilization. a civilization that was able to effectively not only talk about human machine and ecological civilization and that was the release of energy but the beautiful thing about that 8.5 billion civilization this picture is from the 1968 Apollo picture we often talk about this
00:19:48
as the blue dot or the blue blue marble of overview effect I'm going to give you a different narration of that moment That was the moment where the planet became self-aware. The planet was able to perceive itself. The planet had stored enough solar energy, released that to create an 8.5 billion civilization. Remember my thing about the well, sorry, Denise's thing about the toaster and the pencil. We' created that much capacity for the planet to take a picture of itself. That is what had been born.
00:20:31
And so I would argue the thing that we have to preserve is something far more precious than our idea of the civilization. But actually this idea of a planet that is becoming self-aware to which we are party of that intelligence. This is not a theory of ecology versus machine systems versus human systems. It's saying that is a system. Machines are as natural as humans as our e ecological systems. They are part of the planet becoming self-aware. So this is the object form I'm going to put forward to you that is the thing to
00:21:08
preserve and I and it could be argued that might be very very very rare in this galaxy let alone the universe. A planet that has become self-aware and preserving and expanding that optionality is our objective form. Not the continuity of civilization but this other thesis. And in order to do this the challenge becomes is how do we expand this preserve and expand this optionality? It's worth recognizing what our challenge is. We built an economic model and a social economic model that generated vast amounts of optionality.
00:21:53
Energy was used and in the in this moment it's creating externalities and those externalities are feedbacking on itself. So the externalities are now forcing a recoupling of the planet as well as layering an information structure on the planet as well as a monetary system on the planet. All these things and our self-awareness, abilities to sense itself, all these compute capabilities are layering over the planet. Benjamin Bratton does a beautiful job of explaining this stuff, right? So what we have to do and I think this
00:22:26
is where the kind of things become really interesting. If we are facing as we look back at the initial volatility claims that I was making, we have to somehow preserve the optionality, the deep code optionality, we've got to regenerate those environments and we've got to transform them. All just words. Let me give you an example. Pretty much as a result of climate breakdown, every ecological landscape will need to move a 100 miles north or 100 miles south. And unfortunately, evolution won't do it for us because the
00:23:01
speed of those transformations outstrips evolutionary capacity to make those transformations. So, we're already in an environment that there is no theory and this is controversial. So, there's no theory of conserving our ecological systems. We are now in a relationship that we are going to have to regenerate them. Same is true for the Antarctic. Same is true for the Arctic. We are in a situation there is no pathway for us to let go and assume reing will sort the problem out. That means we are now in a
00:23:34
moment that every option has to be about actually yes preserving the resilience regenerating it and also using it as a transformation of where the optionality lies of the future. And I think here when you start to look at the fundamentals, you start to see actually the preservation of optionality is going to require us to reimagine our nutrition supply. You all probably have read Jim, Professor Jim Bllandelle's book on soil. We are now losing, we've lost that arable land around the planet.
00:24:08
I've already talked to you about the 1.7 to 1.9 degrees loss of major food baskets. We're about 40 cycles of agriculture away to losing significant soil damage. We are in a systemically problematized environment with regards to our nutrition landscapes, shelter, energy stability, shared decision-making capacity to name such a such a thing. I'll focus a little bit on shared decision-m capacity. If a society cannot actually perceive, sense, sense, make and make decisions together, it cannot
00:24:41
preserve or manage the risk to which it's facing. So our capacity to make decisions together is a fundamental asset. Right? Democracy is not an overhead on the free market. It's the fundamental means to manage common fates. And I don't mean industrial democracy. I don't mean representative democracy. I mean the idea of actually agentic liberty and to be able to care and cooperate with regards to our common fates. So the tools and mechanisms have to be reimagined. And so in this context the conversations
00:25:19
that we need to think about are not about chocolate optionality, cereal optionality. I don't give a about that. What I'm talking about is soil, energy, water, nutrition, biointegrity, cognitive security. We're talking about foundations. If a society cannot perceive itself, manage itself, actually it isn't cognitively secure in itself. So what are the deep codes of those frameworks? And as I said, conservation is no longer enough. It is no longer sufficient for us to be able to say we bounded a piece
00:25:53
of land and it will sort itself out because of the ecological environments environmental damage that we've already done and the climate breakdown that's already baked in. Right? We will almost certainly at best overshoot some of the limits and pull back over time. And that opens us up to how do we regenerate these common infrastructures around the world fast enough to become both resilient antifragile into that future under under shock. And what this opens up is a way that and I think this is often not talked about
00:26:31
but the demand for a new type class of technologies. And I'm going to talk into this. I don't mean mechanistic technologies. I mean social technical frameworks and capacities in society. And one of the biggest problems that it flows up is how do you drive many to many collaboration and coordination. So the coordination technologies of being able to organize multiple agents into complexity I think is one of the biggest fundamental challenges that we face. And that challenge is also opened up
00:27:04
paradoxically by a capacity that we've also been building. So if the defining coordination technology was competition as a means of coordination, I think one of the things that we have to unleash is how do we swarm innovation? How do we support multiple agents working towards shared goals of say cooling a city in a way that allows for capital and value to be organized in different formats. And here in a place like California and San Francisco, you could argue that machine learning capabilities
00:27:42
are going to open up a new way for us to organize, not through the idea of instruction and instruction as a means of uh control and instructibility, but as placing learning as a means of coordination in a complex environment. environment learning opens up and expands the surface area of our ability to operate in complexity and this is not just a paradigm of technology it's a paradigm of the future of organizing I would argue 21st century organizing is going to be rooted in learning future of the CEO is not chief
00:28:20
executive officer it's chief learning officer being able to pattern the capacity of learning at speed of an organism is going to be its number one framework of utility and In that framework, I think what we have to open up and build is a new class of civilization options. And I want to illustrate what that could look like. And it's a kind of a rhyme with the past. This is a a bridge system that's being grown out of roots in India. And it's been built out of the root infrastructure, living roots, uh out of
00:28:54
tree infrastructure, biological infrastructure, human intervened and grown. Imagine this world view for a terror worldview. Many of you will know the Amazon itself was effectively an open gardened landscape. It was a multiecies open garden landscape. It was not its fertility is a function. It's hyper biodiversity is a function of it being a gardened environment. Now imagine what happens when we talk about building agroforestry futures with precision micro machine autonomous machines acting as key parts of cultivating a multiecies
00:29:35
future. So this is not about divisibility of an ecological human and a machine future. It's about how do these futures come together and what what options do they open up? How do we actually densify the multiecies future is critical for actually improving and preserving soil strength and stroll capabilities? The multiecies capability actually provides multiple business models, value models and contributions biodiversity as well as the technological infrastructure that's required in a diminishing transforming
00:30:06
labor environment where the labor provision is not certainly going to be provided by human capacities over time in a aging demographic in many parts of the world. So what is the option that it opens up? And what I'd like to say is that this this is entirely novel landscape of possibility and it opens up spaces of value not just in the preservation of soil not just in the diversification of nutrition and eco biodiversity but also in new technologies and the capacity of those new technologies. So one of the
00:30:39
conversations that we've been part of is saying our theory of um our theory of how we think about machines is often rooted in control and certainty systems how we conceptually perceive them. Whereas if you were to look back at someone like Darts and read the carts properly, I think one of the most beautiful things he says is I doubt therefore I think therefore I am. And why I prefer the doubt is that if you are all incredibly bright people, probably some of the brightest people in the world. At the same time, none of us
00:31:16
can know everything. It's informationally impossible, computationally impossible. So the only truth that you can genuinely hold is your partial knowing. It's a foundational truth. You only know partial partially of the world. And in that is a beautiful liberation because you must operate with a sense of doubt because your partiality of knowing is a truth. And in that doubt is an invitation of curiosity of somebody else's partial knowing. And in that doubt is a way of being which is rooted in tentiveness,
00:31:54
tenderness and care as a way of being in a complex relatable world. Why that's important is not just for the reimagination of what it means to be human. It's also important for reimagination of what we think machines are, what machines could be in a complex entangled world. So if we use that framework to think about the world, we open up not just kind of options which are about resilience but actually resilience, antifragility and pathways which of new civilization capabilities rooted in doubt, rooted in
00:32:31
tentiveness, tenderness and care as epistemic behaviors of being in complexity. The problem space is that the problem space of operating in rich situational complexity and actually I would argue the technological infrastructure that we're building is allowing us to operate in learning into that situational complexity which was a unique moment we live through the idea of certainty linearity having to simplify the world around us actually we can operate in that complexity that is an extraordinary moment
00:33:05
and this then opens up I I think a series of kind of interesting questions about optionality for who? One of the most profound conversations I had over the last year was somebody of significant wealth basically saying over the next 30 years given the context that we're in I expect to lose 90% of my wealth. This was a very hyperrational, nonquite morally rooted gentleman, right? It wasn't like I I care for the world. It was a very self-interested perspective, but it recognized something really
00:33:46
important. His wealth was fundamentally entangled to the planet and it was fundamentally coupled to it. So that recognition of seeing his wealth coupled to the planet started to change his theory of how actually he had to operate in recognition of that entanglement. So expanding and preserving the optionality of the planet doesn't become a moral choice. It becomes an enlightened self-interest choice of recognizing the terminal pathways we're on. And so at this moment in time, there isn't a divisibility problem between
00:34:26
some and the many. Actually, we start to recognize our shared fate. And we recognize the cascading failures. We recognize that actually the destruction of the social contract isn't just a piece of paper being blown apart. It's effectively about the number of sociopaths and psychopaths we create that we traumatize into the world with access to asymmetric weaponizable technologies which we've largely democratized with bioweapons and other landscapes. We are non-ivisibly linked. Our fates have become systematically
00:35:06
coupled. The quicker we realize that with either the mats or the enlightenment perspective, it doesn't really matter now. Those two things are so co-joining. And the cost of large scale harm, you saw this with drones. You can see this with any of the other stuff. I won't go into this. There's better, more complete people talking about this. Has collapsed into virtually zero. And that is forcing a coupling. And the cascades don't stay local anymore in any format because actually whether it's CO2, it's
00:35:44
basically CO2 is effectively a planetary coupling device. Our fates here become entangled with everyone else's fates. The UK obviously where where I live, United Kingdom fundamentally is indivisibly entangled to the fate of the Antarctic. If we lose the Antarctic ice shelves, we talk about 65 meter rise in water levels. There is no meaningful UK. So I'm not asking for moral universal ideas of justice. I'm asking for just being smart. I'm not looking for any morality here. I think morality is a function of
00:36:28
divisibility, separation from the planet. I'm just asking you to be self-aware and enlighten self-interest to recognize our systemic entanglements and operate in a radically new way to avoid this and I think optionality for everyone is because optionality breakdown. down is going to affect us all. We won't have a New Zealand pathway. loads of evidence to say why that New Zealand pathway doesn't has not worked will not work in this futures and in this context I think wealth and strength as it's now often been talked
00:37:21
about is concentrated claim on the capacity of future making and that's fine only in recognition of those entanglements because they're non-ivisibly available. And this creates a different form of relationship of how we operate in the world. And this requires us to start to think about these foundational economies and reimagining every one of those foundational economies that I spoke about under those cascade conditions. And again repeating there is no fortress pathway in a mutually assured f destructive future.
00:38:18
So our capacity to expand the option space and it's not just the preservation of the current option space to expand the option space otherwise we end up with a zero sum game future which actually will be mutually destructive becomes really critical. So I would say in that context optionality is the avail the choice of available futures to us where we have the capacity to operate and react to uncertainty and risks in a way that we cannot perceive and expanding that becomes a critical need. So the question then becomes where do we
00:39:01
act? I've mentioned so many of these before. Soil erosion, foundational goods. And again, I'm not just talking about permaculture. I'm talking about new technologies and capacities to be able to govern and organize soil in radical new ways and to be able to deal with that to avoid this cascade failure. Water stress. Right now, we're looking to lose likely most glacias, certainly in the Alps and many parts of the Himalayas. The Himalayas is responsible for the hydraological cycle of about 3.5 billion
00:39:39
people with at least three nuclear powers. Remember, you don't have to wait for the end goal of losing glacias. You have to wait for the volatility effects to be significant enough to actually violence to become the dominant way of resolving those conflicts. Atmospheric governance more and more it's very clearly recognizable certainly from the UK models. If we lose the amark current, our capacity, most of the UK will become unfarmmable because of actually the hydraological cycle will weaken so significantly. So our ability
00:40:13
to govern atmospheres and to be able to actually actively govern atmospheres. So we're only at the beginning of this story with effectively cloud seeding and drones used to collect cloud seeding and and design waterfalls as autonomous institutions. We are at the beginning of a new theory of how we govern into these environments. how you deal with cities like Madrid which are looking at 47 degrees temperature in middle of summer and when we talk about these temperatures I just want to humanize all these conversations
00:40:45
this is and some of this stuff has already happened in fact it happened to a friend of mine Yos Bundman his his close friend passed away he was effectively hadn't slept it was too hot at night he got into a car in the morning and fell asleep in the are in Madrid or whether it's domestic abuse that increases as a result of these temperature cascades or whether it's actually transformers that break down which means the continuity whiplash effect in supply chains or whether it's the maintenance costs of roads and
00:41:18
everything else or whether it's the IQ drops that happen as a result of the heat effects. At the same time, what we recognize is many of these environments won't be the first movers. The hard constraint is it's very difficult to do this sort of work in the Himalayas. You may need to do it in the Alps where the need can be understood and the politics political thickness exists to be able to build the new institutional infrastructures and the talent density to be able to do what's
00:41:50
required. So where geographies where risk is legible, politics can hold and talent can orchestrate, these are the locations where these futures can be built and they will need to be built at speed. And this opens up the how question. Cooling Madrid is not a single product problem. It is not unfortunately the optimization of a single product or a single enterprise problem. Cooling Madrid is a multi-point intervention problem. Portfolio of interventions are required and to be innovated to deal with the
00:42:26
cooling effect. A lot of our theory of innovation has been rooted in the theory of the startup. This is the home of the startup. The challenge that we face is we're going to have to cool cities which is going to cost billions and it's going to require multiple interventions at different landscapes, different products, different ways of measuring, different ways of actually cooling those different ways of automating those environments. Whole plethora of activities not just for that for glacia
00:42:56
stabilization. It's not a single product problem and the bottleneck is typically organizational. So to cool Madrid isn't just about cooling Madrid. It's about actually pooling risks across multiple actors. Thousand actors, 10,000 actors. How do you pull that risk that allows for multiple interventions to be allocated situationally and spatially to be able to manage that risk in a spatial sense? How do you finance that? There's a wrapper problem which is fundamental to be able to organize the technologies,
00:43:30
the physical technologies and beyond to manage this reality. Here I'm going to put forward a word executions. Not closed bounded institutions, not startups, new ways of organizing that allow us to be able to manage these largecale multi-actor problem spaces without boundaries. These are rooted in new types of capabilities like how do you pull liabilities across mass multi- aent actors? How do you construct deeper tractors for the future? Recognizing and comprehending the risk, especially when
00:44:04
the risk sometimes makes you unviable. So, one of the biggest challenges that we face, and I I'm sure Denise and I will talk about this, fundamentally when you start to price some of the effects of this stuff, most of our economic enterprises don't make it through. They're nonviable. How do you construct the politics? How do you engineer the politics for these realities? How do you build an outcome accelerator which is rooted in hitting a 7.5 degree goal of cooling a city recognizing the
00:44:33
innovations are yes startup yes policy yes civic participation yes new forms of infrastructure yes new forms of supply chain innovation which have to be coordinated to orchestrate for that goal this requires a team of entrepreneurs working together in a different way so one of my provocations for us here is that maybe the kind of institution of change which was in 2001 onwards the startup maybe this institution of driving change in the 21st century will have to be a new means of organizing rooted in a different theory.
00:45:08
How do you capitalize this? This is not a capitalization problem of like it's a capitalization problem of two billion to cool a city and how do we build these forms? Everything I'm saying here isn't hypothetical analysis. Most of what I'm saying are actually pathways that we are in the process of either building with our partners and in our relationships. How do you cool Madrid in many ways is a real problem not just for Madrid for many cities. How do you stabilize the Alps and regenerate regenerate the water
00:45:51
hydraological systems is a real problem for the 21st century. I think one thing I've not mentioned well enough in this conversation has been I think one of the fundamental questions I'm holding is what's the value of being human? And I think if we cannot transform our theory of value of being human, the value of being human is diminishing, diminishing rapidly. Return on labor has been actually stagnant if not declining relative to return of assets. In that reality, what we're seeing is not just a
00:46:24
devaluation of being human, but the inability to be able to finance the education and health infrastructures relative to that diminishing value of being human. So as we transform our machine logics which you know California is the center of, we need to pay equal and maybe even greater attention of what is the future value of being human and how do we build a new theory of human machine logics rooted not in not in certainty and opinion but in conversation in doubt in curiosity. What is a new logic of organizing in that
00:46:59
reality? How do you finance bio regions and not just bio regions in terms of actually one project I mean largecale landscapes in terms of actually soil preservation water rejuvenation multiecies nutrition landscapes biomeaterial landscapes all the way through to micro autonomous machines and farming infrastructure to new provenence mechanisms which actually are not extractive but actually systemically generative. How do we build the capacity for societies to be able to decide together? Representative democracy, whilst great,
00:47:41
only works with the idea of a relatively simple world or a linear world. Our ability to be able to organize in complexity is failing because we are still trying to live in a 19th century theory of decisions in a surface landscape that doesn't work. and you've built the technology to be able to already house it. I think some of the kind of large scale learning models are opening up a new human machine landscape to be able to organize new ways of conversation, new conversational theory which isn't rooted
00:48:12
in valorization of opinion but the capacities for societies to have complex discourses. What does it mean to create fertile societies? And I don't mean biological fertility. I mean societies to be able to hold fertility at a systematic level. So as I close this talk and I come close to it, what I want to say is for me these are not theoretical conversations. These are the landscapes where I think fundamental decisions and questions will be made about how we see the 21st century. I remember many years ago there was often these
00:48:56
conversations about what does global governance look like and the thing that gave me greatest pos sort of imagination of the future was looking back at the river Danube. The river Danube in Europe was where international waters was born at the conflict between 12 different nations. They gave birth to the idea of international waters. I think in the landscape that we're talking about in these futures that we're talking about is our theory of governing, organizing, and capitalizing the 21st century in
00:49:29
radical new pathways. But it's going to be found in these sites of discovery. And it's going to require us to be able to open up and imagine and work out a whole bunch of problems that we don't know how to solve. How do you understand these cascade risk? How do you put maths behind these cascade risks? How do you understand a completely different part of the equation which is often not bought into the table? This is London numbers, but I I assume you could do this for San Francisco very quickly. The total value
00:50:02
at risk in London, right? Just on residential property is 3.8 million homes. 668,000 is the average price of a home in pounds. That means the current total value at risk is 2.52 trillion. Not billion, not million, trillion. So when we talk about these cascading figures, we're working off the economics of that background. Not the marginal gains of growth, not the marginal gains of job job discovery and losses. We're working on that scale of numbers. How do we I've given you some examples
00:50:45
of the critical locations where we're going to have to introduce these firerekes. Where are these fire brakes? How do we capitalize them? How do we finance them? How do we build machineass assisted learning infrastructures? I think the deepest revolution is going to almost certainly be in our shift of our theory of organizing in two different frameworks. Our organizing theory is rooted largely in control and instruction. recognizing humans as poor machines to actually learning becoming the foundational framework and unbounded
00:51:18
organizing being the second second framework. So moving from bounded theory of corporation to non-bounded theory of organizing rooted in learning that's the paramatic move that I think we'll have to make to be able to deal with a coupling entangled world. It's not a dream. It's just the means of organizing. How do we thicken them? Uh, Marov's blankets in terms of actually giving us enough time and speed, time and capacity to be able to support um the preprintance of of that decoupling
00:51:53
or that space and time. How do we do that? We're going to have to do that. Thicken those environments. What are the new forms of capital? Yes, what's the role of fiat money? But then also, what's the role of stable coins? what's the role of next economics around this stuff, these are all going to be opened up in many of these landscapes and I think also stuff like the valorization of opinion or the valorization of conversation and conversation holds much greater bandwidth to be able to discuss and
00:52:26
converse about the complexities of the world than any form of opinion. This is why I find for example you know I was often accused that India your language is too complicated it's great for Westminster or whatever but it doesn't work in the real ground and actually my lived reality was completely different if you actually speak with people on the ground I remember one gentleman 89 year old gentleman walked up to me and so said hey Andy I didn't get every word you said but you put words into what I
00:52:56
was feeling and the objective is the conversation not the opinion. The bandwidth of what's made available as a result of that is much larger. The surface area of coordination and organization is much larger and machine assisted capabilities are opening up a landscape of possibility which I think will be systemically revolutionary around those things. How do we build that shared perception of risk? I go back originally to my point. If I'm hungry today, I don't have a shared perception of risk with you.
00:53:26
And that means we have a fragment fragmented capacity to be able to organize How do we pull these liabilities? How do we build an outcome accelerator? And the reason I'm saying all these questions is these are questions that we are dealing with and we don't yet have answers. Right? This is my invitation to all of you. These are vast problem spaces that we are going to have to resolve and solve in different ways. And this talk for me is an invitation. And behind these questions, I guarantee you there are
00:53:58
other questions. Forget about outcome accelerators, organizing them, term sheets, value distribution between multiple lead value points, a whole bunch of questions after questions. But we are going to have to solve them. And I think this is a surface area that's going to yield vast amounts of benefits to be able to organize around that. How do you build the deep attractors for these sorts of futures? We played with the term what is a prophecy lab? Think about the term the prophecy lab. Can we engineer deep attractors as we've
00:54:28
done previously to be able to create deep attractors for a different future? What would it mean to engineer those environments? What are those conversations? What's the legitimacy around these conversations? And this is where I sort of say we don't have pre-coded answers for this, but we certainly think these questions are valid and need to be explored and need to be capitalized. And that's some of what we're doing. And the pathway here and I think it's only we are living in a fork a fork
00:54:59
between mutually assured destruction and mutually assured thriving. It's not much of a choice. You know that's uh Jurassic Park lovely quote. Life wants to live well let's live. [applause] And I think this is where why this conversation I'm really grateful to Denise, Rebecca, the board. I think there's a genuine question about everyone everywhere long now. Not a long now for the few, but a genuine long now for the expansion of the planet which has become self-aware. I think that is a interesting
00:55:43
invitation for all of us. And that is the work that I think we are all holding together in many ways. With that, I'm going to thank you. [applause] [applause] All right. How was that? [applause] >> Fantastic. Thank you so much, Indie. Also, of all the things that we talked about, the toaster uh stuck. And I actually wanted to pick up on the toaster because it came up in the context of thinking about fundamental entanglements at the nation state level. And we're in we're in a world in which politics is becoming
00:56:38
rivalous again where nations are trying to reerect uh borders and talk about national sovereignty. And what we were discussing was this idea that nations are essentially flows of all kinds and that it doesn't actually make sense to bound ourselves in the way that we've been bound and that we're subject to all kinds of planetary dynamics that are not governable at the planet or sorry at the nation state level. And so I'm wondering if you can expand on that. Um, and the toaster was essentially this idea that
00:57:14
no one country can actually make a toaster on its own. It's even though it has seven component parts, you need to source that material from a complex supply chain, the manufacturing, even something as simple as a toaster, no one nation state can do on its own. So can you talk to us about the geopolitics of this moment and how to actually assert a planetary perspective in the context of nations trying to reassert this very bounded notion of relationality. >> Yeah. I mean I think there's I'll talk
00:57:48
from a UK perspective because I'm a little bit more familiar. The UK I would best describe the UK as a knot in global flows. It's a knot of flows and to govern the UK it would be a mistake to think you could govern the boundary of the UK and if you recognize it as an interdependent knot like I said UK is existentially linked to the Antarctic. UK is existentially linked to the Amazon. Any delusion that UK would survive without those ecological contributions is like just a delusion. So if we start to see ourselves in
00:58:28
entanglement and in relationship, I think our theory of governance doesn't go from what I'd call planetary collective but situational and relational and the object form of the UK becomes actually in relationship to Kenyan soils in relationship to the longevity and the mutual development of those environments rather than an extractive relationship because it destabilizes those contexts and itself in that time. So I think there's a third position that we often we you know we often fall into the kind of the two
00:58:58
conversations I've witnessed even here is this idea of the the universal good like we pretend everyone's great and we sort of all act for the common good. It's kind of there's been an active critique of that reality. And then the other thing is the vesalian state which is the bounded theory. I think there's an intermediary position which is enlightened self-interest through a systems lens recognizing mutual development as a pathway to stabilize your own realities as well. I think that that works. I
00:59:31
think it's available to us. I think the science supports that stuff. I think it creates a different landscape. >> Um, one of the things that struck me in your talk was and that I found very compelling was this notion of optionality. Um and one of the questions I had was you know in thinking about the rise of our human civilization over the last even 50 to 70 years where we have now created as you said an 8.5 billion person civilization that has come at the expense of the optionality of the biosphere and you
01:00:06
know we've radically reduced biodiversity and so I'm curious to hear from you how do we negotiate the types of optionalities. How do we negotiate between the optionalities we're creating for more humans on the one side and decreasing optionality for the biosphere on the other and and then also now with you know agentic capacity how do we negotiate between the optionalities we're trying to create? >> I think I mean I think it's it's perhaps the most complex question available. Um
01:00:38
but I would and it's true right this is I but I also would say that you know I often sit in a room and somebody will say well okay this negotiation but the hard reality is that it's about a billion people in the world that are actually living multiple times the planet. It's about 7.5 billion which are perfectly within planetary boundaries. And then I think when you look back at this is why I use the example of terapreta and the Amazon you start to realize that our industrial logics and
01:01:16
our means of organizing fundamentally are systemically deeply unproductive over time. They're efficient in terms of capital but they're not systemically productive. So I think we are opening up a pathway where terror futures were multiecies open open gardening far more diversity far more nutrition available to us in history and with new technologies we're able to do that at a type of scale that we could never do before and a contribution of labor which has transformed. So I think the
01:01:45
optionality expansion isn't just about negotiation between the lifestyles we want to lead. That's why I'm saying I think we're going to have to go back to the root level of these foundational goods and reimagine how we construct that space. So I I have a kind of deep hope that there's something extraordinary available when we start to move outside the industrial logics of simplification and seeing like a state James Scott's book of seeing like a state and monolithic systems as a means
01:02:14
of making sense of the world. when we can embrace that complexity and situational variance which I think is now technologically and bureaucratically available to us whether it's kind of summer of protocols work that's been going on victra or like a whole bunch of other work that's been going on that's opening up these landscapes smart contracts open up a contingent landscape a parametric landscape of organizing we are creating a whole new bureaucratic regime which I think is able to absorb
01:02:39
that surface area complexity and actually build much more situational variety which we will never be able to hold historically Even the theory of material governance I think are mechanisms. So for example if you have a timber house in reality what you have is an obligation to steward that timber for 500 years. You own the liability of the carbon stored in that tim that house for 500 years. We haven't had the institutional frameworks outside theories of ownership and ownership includes the right of
01:03:09
abuse and burning to be able to actually think about material stewardship chains, open means of organizing that. So I think there's capabilities that are available for us to be able to organize these different forms of economy in radical new ways and I think that sophistication I think max will unleash a type of optionality we've not perceived before and at different layers as well. Could I ask you? So, you shared something with us last night about all of us being bad capitalists. Um, can you
01:03:39
can you provoke us here tonight with the same? >> Yeah. I mean, >> I mean, there's a part of me and this is there's a part of me just sits here and says if you look at the risk profile and you look at where value sits, there is a fundamental arbitrage right now available between what we're pricing and where value and risk lies. And I'm not asking for any form of enlightenment. I'm just saying follow the numbers and the science. There is an extraordinary moment available like once in multiple
01:04:12
generations available to be able to arbitrage where value lies and what we're pricing. And they are totally out of whack. And the science is giving us the numbers. We just aren't able to absorb them because we're locked into paradigms that are actually old-fashioned and unable to price them. And so part of me is just sitting there going, "This is no longer a moral debate, right? I don't sit here. If I was sitting here five years ago, 2016 or whatever, it'd be like, hey, would be
01:04:41
great. Let's be better people." I'm I'm not asking for any inner development work. I don't think you need it anymore. The numbers the the numbers of losses that we're talking about make it very evident there is a different theory of value available and what could be organized. So in a sense, I think I'm just asking us to be shitheot capitalists right now to be able to shot understand that risk framework and to be able to organize against that framework in a really really smart way. And I
01:05:09
think that's entirely for enlightened self-interest. I'm not even also asking for any form of altruism or do goodness in a kind of I'm just saying be smart intergenerationally. Be smart as to the theory of risk and value. Allocate and move. I think the conversation we were having at breakfast today too was essentially that there are real and legitimate institutional barriers for capital owners, for asset owners and asset allocators to recoup themselves to the economic logic that you're providing. Um, but if you
01:05:43
were, and I know I'm sure there are folks in in the room tonight who are capital allocators, maybe you work for a family office or um, in venture or in in some other framework. Um, what would you advise them to do and how would they know that they're on the right path to the type of value capture that you're describing? [snorts] So first thing I I think if you're institutional capital I fully recognize institutional capital is right now bounded and structured into an old worldview at multiple layers.
01:06:16
So this is where I think family officers have a unique strength because they actually they can start to take a different risk profile with regards to the world view. Second, I think I would actually have a world view. Like genuinely, [laughter] I'd stop like even if you're an institutional capital holder, build a world view because I don't think I've seen capital holders really systemically look at the risk profile and say, how are we allocating capital and what's the impact? And some of the best funds,
01:06:45
right, really good guys have not even done that, let alone the not so good guys. So, I think those two differentials. Third, actually I think the pathway of risk, like I was saying, I'm less and less. Forget about when London gets to minus 20 plus 40. Worry about the volatility effects. And I think there's a different risk model. And I think there's work required into those risk models. Focus on the volatility and what you should be pricing against is I think the biggest worry is how fast we cascade into total
01:07:17
value at risk and expose that total value at risk in ways that we've never talked about before. And I think those risks are all available. So I think there's work to be done around this stuff. And I also think continuity value will be really critical. So continuity of water, continuity of energy, continuity of nutrition supply. These will have high levels premium for actually stabilizing those assets. The economics, we've been doing a lot of work around security economics, security and stability economics. There is a
01:07:44
different economic logic that starts to become manifest in some of those realities as well. So again, none of my stuff is right now in any form of like be nice, be kind. I just think it's be smart. >> Oh, thank you so much. Um, just before we turn to audience questions, um, I think on that point about risk, you know, risk management is different than risk mitigation, right? And I think most of our institutions have a risk management perspective for their own portfolios or their own, you
01:08:17
know, set of things that they're they're um they're orienting around. But that's and that's different than figuring out how to proactively invest in resilience or invest in mitigation from some of these cascading risks that you've described. And can you is there a way in which you can see the possibility of changing that dynamic from a kind of make sure I'm managing my own risk i.e. my own pension fund or whatever uh the liabilities that I currently have to actively and proactively allocating
01:08:51
capital in a way that would you know contribute to the mitigation of the risk. I think the problem is there is no way to keep portfolio portfolio in financializing that risk at the scale that it's it's replicating outside. >> So if you just take an inward strategy, I think it's a diminishing returns and diminishing it's a demise strategy. Frankly, the value is going to be about how you operate with a risk on perspective and managing external risk and being able to find leverage points
01:09:17
into that. So I think this is a you know in a way that you guys are the heart of venture capital. Venture capital is fundamentally a risk-on model. I think this is that moment for you to be proactively engaged into those risk frameworks. Looking at the arbitrage between value and price in fundamentally different ways. Looking at the generative derivative technologies that are going to be born in this reality. Looking at stability as a delta function and all that all that reality. I think stability is going to be far more
01:09:43
valuable than than people are currently pricing as volatility increases. So I think all of these things are now available. I think it requires us I'll go back to the point that was said earlier. I think it requires us to be better capitalists. >> Okay, a couple of audience questions here. So this is from Joseph. What are the examples where optionality provides a first order positive influence on innovation, economics or governance? >> I I would say there's a vast movement of
01:10:12
brilliant people working around bio regionalism. I think if you look at the stability and the risk threats with regards to nutrition supply, soil loss, bi biointegrity losses that we're starting to see, water, other forms of I would argue that actually restoring and rebuilding our agroforestry landscapes, our water infrastructure, our soil densities, that itself is a one of the most fundamental and I think it's I'm just talking about the effects. I'm just talking about the offtake, but actually
01:10:44
on top of that is a whole new class of um technologies and capabilities that I think are going to be really critical in being able to organize this world. That to me is one dimension of just an explosion of not just what I would call longitudinal asset which is the soil or whether it's the biioaterials and the nutrition economy or the soil the water effects or the the fire risk management or the derivative technologies or the provincial provenence and standards technologies that whole stack of values
01:11:13
available and I think that to me is one of those things where you are not only providing resilience not only providing continuity you're providing building anti-fragility but also derivative technologies. That's a full stack available. >> Um, so something I'm reflecting on as I'm listening to you and to the talk is that perhaps there's a bit of a paradox in what I've heard you share, which is on the one hand that we have these new technologies, we have a new type of
01:11:40
planetary sapiens where we have the ability or or we have the capacity perhaps to move towards better management of these incredibly complex systems dynamics. on the other hand, you're encouraging us to embrace doubt and em embrace a partiality of knowing. Um, [snorts] and so I'm wondering if you can speak to that. And one of the the questions here is, is doubt foundational to intelligence? >> Um, yes. Uh, I doubt but I think I mean like I personally like it, you know, when I was reading Darts and I was sort of like I
01:12:17
doubt therefore I think is a better paraphrase of what his first paragraph was felt so structurally more interesting at every level. And I think one of the things that just kind of like has been haunting me is just this stack of logic which is if I can't know everything I fundamentally the only awareness I can hold is my partiality of knowing that is like okay I can't that is informationally true once I inhabit that reality then my curiosity of Denise or anyone here is not like oh wouldn't I'm curious
01:12:57
because I love to be curious. It's like it's the only way I expand my partiality of knowing. And if that's true and recognizing my partiality of knowing, tentiveness, tenderness, and care are not like care of something. It's a way of being in the world. Tentiveness, tenderness is a way of being. You've all probably seen some of these self-arning machines which are actually reorganized dynamically to be able to actually find ways of walking and learning. and they are finding their own path of
01:13:28
organizing. So I think there's a way of being in complexity which I think it's fundamentally rooted in partial knowing curiosity of learning learning oriented coherence that becomes really interesting. So yeah I would say I think it's a way of being it doesn't discount us from expanding our possibility. It doesn't say that we we can't know more. doesn't remove the idea of action but it roots the action in a theory of hypothesis and inquiry and questionoriented organizing which I
01:14:00
think is really interesting. >> So is it um can I say something back to you and you tell me if if this is correct. So is it that we can take that partiality of knowing that to me feels very intuitive at at the personal level um as one small being amongst 8.5 billion um but that we can we can imbue that within our organizations which are themselves living complex dynamic ecosystems that have feedback loops of learning and that there's a there's a way in which doubt can feature in our executions as you say um but in
01:14:36
in our instit initutions in ways that allow them to become continuously learning entities over time. >> Exactly. And the kind of object form becomes the conversation. So if I am partial in knowing and you're partial in knowing, the really interesting thing is the conversation, >> right? >> And the conversation if you valorize the conversation rather than the opinion, then the conversational dynamic is the means of actually intelligence. So intelligence is not my position or your
01:15:04
position. It's the meta possession of the conversational field that's evolving and I think that's much more interesting than this kind of anthropotic uh internalization of intelligence seeing it as a meta capability of the system and that's where I think conversation for me is the unit unit product here. Um, we had a few questions that were sort of oriented around a theme of looking at past civilizations and um, what we can glean from, as an example, societies which gardened the Amazon uh,
01:15:39
but also how to retain some of that civilizational knowledge over time um, when there's the potential for it to be lost. And so perhaps prefiguring some of your notions of, you know, systemic collapse or cascading cascading risk, are there ways that we could anticipate preserving uh the knowledge that we thus far have gleaned as a civilization? [snorts] >> I mean, I think there's much much better people than me to talk about some of this stuff. I mean I I mean personally I would like I think the anthropologist
01:16:14
David Greyber's work on Dawn of Everything in terms of his comprehension of the multiple pathways of civilizational ideas that expand some of our realities that I think we're we're locked into. I also think this is a moment which rhymes with the past but isn't necessarily the past. So I think we're living in a moment where the explosion of sovereignties and the explosion of interbeing or interbecoming a development of mechanisms they rhyme with ways of how we used to see the
01:16:41
world in an animistic world view but I think that's being made available with new technologies and new ways of organizing which are radical and new. So I think we have societies we as a society are moving into a different phase of embracing some of those realities. Whether I think there are new ways of I'm sure and like there are brilliant people looking at some of this stuff. What are the vaults of knowledge that we need to create into this future? U I'm sure there's better people in the
01:17:08
audience about that stuff. >> Um okay I want to do one last audience question which is going to take us in a different direction. >> Sure. Um but and gosh I just lost the card. Where did it go? But it was essentially around the notion that we live in a world um oh here it is. See I was saving it in a special place. Um we live in we live in a world where planetary coordination is might be more difficult as a result of being in a cont a context of mostly monotheistic esquetologies that are based on endtime
01:17:46
salvation and you know um a messiah coming for us to save us one day. And so the question is as breakdown increases we might expect the power of these types of uh politics and and worldviews to increase. And so how might we how might we break through with this kind of planetary perspective that you are offering us to build really wide ranging constituencies around this shared optimism of the future. >> Wow. [laughter] >> That was from Ashoka. So you can thank Ashoka later for that one.
01:18:20
>> Thank you. I'll buy you a drink. [laughter] Um I mean I I'm sort of wide ranging but that is going wide. So I think the way I suppose I look at this is that I I come from a faith of see sikism and what I think has made it interesting for me in sikism God is not a thing out there. Everything is God. So it's a non-divisible reality to a world view. And I think some of the problems I think like if you were to chart a theory of our relationship there's a beautiful book by Sophie
01:19:02
Strand called um flowering wand which talks about different theories of masculinity and pre-arthian mas masculinity and talks about the power of the wand partnership societies and and non monotheic religious sun god societies and how we had different relationship with land different relationships of being with the planet So I think I mean I would argue that we are on a course of a new form of evolution. And I think this is why for me there was a kind of profound moment when if when I remember thinking about
01:19:36
that blue marble picture and saying what if this was a planet perceiving itself and if you see it from that lens I think it changes our relationship with ourselves but also our relationship with our own divisibility for the planet. So I think there are new ways of perceiving the world. I think there's new ways of being in the world, being with the world, but also transforming our think our own theory of self. And maybe the way I'll take the question is that the most radical question right now is not
01:20:08
what the future of AI. The most radical question I think on the available is what's the future of being human. I think every revolution has almost always reinvented the [clears throat] idea of what it means to be human and I think it is the underdeveloped thesis and I think there's something extraordinary available there and I think that's the question that I think San Francisco and California should be holding in parallel with the extraordinary work that is going on and difficult work actually in adjacent to
01:20:44
the future of machine learning, what is the future of being human? And I think there's something magical available there. If you talk to neuroscientists, if you talk to sort of some of the kind of work that's already going on, there's a completely different path. So between the blue marble picture of the planet perceiving itself and this kind of expansion of what it means to be human, I think there's something that may be able to break us free from some of the locks that we've got into
01:21:09
history. Um, I wanted to end with a quote from Stuart Bran, um, who is very quotable. Um, but I thought this was very resonant with your talk, which is he says, "None of us can save the world, but we can all set in motion a self-saving world." And I wonder if you might leave all of us with um an encouragement as we as we leave here tonight. If there's one thing that we could do to bring about to set in motion a self-saving world, to set in motion a world which in increases optionality, which increases resilience.
01:21:49
Um what would you like us to take away? Um, I think the number one thing that sort of I would like us to walk away with is this idea that I think we're facing a fork, not a choice. And the choice is do we want to live? And I think it's as profound and structural as that. And when you look at the world through this lens and mutually assured thriving is the only viable pathway, I think the options and the ways of perceiving the world radically change. And I would argue that you are sitting
01:22:37
in a place of an extraordinary opportunity of being able to radically imagine into that world. I think some of the core capabilities that have been built here are going to be an essential and fundamental building block of that future. But I fear we're still trapped into the institutional forms of the 19th century with the capacity to organize in a radically different way. So how do we organize for this world? I think is the innovative step and the transformative step. And maybe this is where the
01:23:13
provocation would really sit if California and San Francisco in 2001 was the birthplace of the startup as a means of organizing value. I think the question is what is the form of organizing value in 2026 and I provoke and challenge you that I don't think it's the startup. >> I love it. Um, also someone should should start the YC outcomes accelerator. Um, uh, thank you so much for being with us, Indie. This was phenomenal. We're so thrilled to have you and thank you all for being here
01:23:48
tonight. [applause] Thanks. [music]