Articles
Library
Videos
Lunar Calendar
Quantum Sexuality
Playgrounds
Friends &Β Mentors
Work With Me
Exit
🌍
Timeline
πŸ—‚
Sequences
πŸ“‘
Influence
πŸ“°
Articles
πŸ“š
Books
🎬
Videos
πŸŒ–
Lunar Calendar
πŸ”₯
Sexuality
πŸ“‹
Notes
πŸ‘€
Friends & Mentors
πŸ“
Playgrounds
un
identified
Contents
> Video> Summary> Highlights> Key Insights> Featured> Extended Analysis> Conclusion> Sequences> Related Videos> Transcript

Alan Watts - Time

Summary

Highlights

Key Insights

Extended Analysis

Conclusion

SEQUENCES

No items found.

Related Books

TRANSCRIPT

00:00:32
Time is a very difficult thing to pin down as a famous saying of st., Augustine of Hippo That when he was asked what his time. He said I know what it is, but when you ask me I don't And yet it seems absolutely fundamental to our life Time is money we say I don't have enough time time flies time drags and I think we should go into the question of what this is because in our ordinary common sense We think of time as a one-way motion from the past through the present and on into the future and

00:01:14
That carries along with it another impression which is to say That life moves from the past to the future in such a way That what happens now, and what will happen is always the result of what has happened in the past In other words we seem to be driven along You know once upon a time. It was fashionable in psychology For people to speak of man's and animals instincts that we had for example an instinct for survival an instinct to make love and so on but nowadays that word has become unfashionable and psychologists tend instead to use the word drives and

00:02:09
To speak of the need for food as a drive the need for survival or for sex as drives And that's a very significant word because it's brought out isn't it by people who feel driven I? Must say personally if I feel hungry, I don't feel driven, also if I feel lusty I don't feel driven Because I don't say excuse me But I have to eat or excuse me. I need to fulfill my sexual urges my biological impulses I say hooray I identify myself with my drives They're me, and I don't take a passive attitude towards them and apologize for them

00:03:01
So the whole idea of our being driven is connected with the idea of causality of life moving Under the power of the past and that Is so ingrained in our common sense that it's very difficult to get rid of it because I want to turn the thing round Completely the other way and say That The past is the result of the present Let us suppose just for the sake of example that this universe Started with a big bang as some cosmologists believe Now when that bang happened it was the present wasn't it and

00:03:54
So the universe began in what we will call a now moment Then it goes on doing its stuff and Always when any Event that we now called past came into being it came into being in the present and out of the present That's one way of seeing it But before we get further involved in this. I want to draw your attention to a fallacy in the very common-sense idea of causality that Events Are caused by previous events from which they flow or result? necessarily To understand the fallacy of that idea we have to begin by asking what do you mean by an event?

00:04:56
Let's take the event of a human being coming into the world Now when does that event begin Does it occur at the moment of parturition when the baby actually comes out of its mother or Does the baby begin at the moment of conception Or does the baby begin when it was an evil gleam in its father's eye Or does a baby begin when The spermatozoa are generated in the father or the ovum in the mother Or could you say a baby begins when its father is born or when its mother is born? All these things can be thought of as beginnings

00:05:49
But we decide for purposes of legal registration that a life begins at the moment of partition and that is a purely arbitrary decision and It has validity only because we all agree about it Let me show you the same phenomenon in the dimension of space instead of the dimension of time Let's ask how big is the son? Are we going to define the son as Limited by the extent of its fire That's one possible definition But we could equally well define the sphere of the son By the extent of its heat

00:06:38
we could also define the sphere of the son by the extent of its light and Each of these would be reasonable choices except that it's rather difficult to keep track of the extent of its light because we're inside it and Therefore we have arbitrarily agreed to define the son by the limit of its visible far But you will see in all these bye-bye-bye these analogies that How big a thing is or how long an event is is simply a matter of definition? Now therefore when by simple definition for purposes of discussion we have

00:07:25
Divided events into certain periods we'll say the first world war began in 1914 and it ended in 1918 now actually all those things which led up to the first world war started long before 1914 and the repercussions of that war have continued long beyond 1918 How are we to distinguish an event from its repercussions? So you will see that because we have divided events From one another in this arbitrary way we do that and then we sort of forget we did it and Then we have a puzzle how do events lead to each other?

00:08:09
Because you see in reality. There are no separate events life moves along like water and It's all connected as the source of a river is connected to the mouth and to the ocean and All the events or things going on are like whirlpools in the stream Because you go there today, and you see a whirlpool you go there tomorrow, and you see a whirlpool But it isn't the same whirlpool because all the water is changing every second What is happening is not really what we should call a? whirlpool, but rather a wall pooling it is an activity not a thing and

00:08:53
Indeed every so-called thing can be called an event We call say a house housing we call a mat matting and We could equally call a cat a cat Inge so we could say the catting sat on the matting and We would thereby have a word in which there were no things but only events To give another illustration a flame is something we say there is a flame on the candle But it would be more correct to say there is a flaming on the candle because the flame is a stream of hot gas let's take another amusing example we say fist and

00:09:36
Fist is a noun and fist looks like a thing but suddenly what happens to the fist when I opened my hand See I was fisting now. I'm handing Handing it to you so every kind of so-called thing can be spoken of as an event and Because events flow into each other the fisting flows into the handing We cannot say exactly Where one ends and the other begins? So therefore if we remember that we shall see that we do not need the idea of causality to explain how a prior event Influences a following event because it's like this

00:10:25
supposing I'm looking through a narrow slit in a fence and a snake goes by I've never seen a snake before and this is mysterious, and I see through the slit in the fence first the snake's head Then I see a long trailing body, and then finally the tail I Said well that was interesting Then the snake turns round and goes back and again. I see first the head and then after an interval the tail Now if I call the head one event and the tail another it will seem to me that the event head is the cause of the event tail and

00:11:11
The tail is the effect but if I look at the whole snake I Will see a head tailed snake And it would be simply absurd To say that the head of the snake is the cause of the tail as if the head came in is if the snake came in being first the head and then the tail The snake comes into being out of its egg as a head tailed snake And so in exactly the same way all Events are really one event We're looking when we talk about different events we're looking at different sections or parts of one

00:11:52
continuous happening and Therefore The idea of separate events which have to be linked by a mysterious process called cause and effect Is completely unnecessary? But having thought that way we think of present events as being caused by past events and therefore we tend to regard ourselves as the puppets of the past as driven along by Something that is always behind us now To overcome this impression, it's very simple you begin again with an experiment, which I suggested in a previous talk about meditation

00:12:49
Approach the world through your ears If you shut your eyes and make contact with reality Purely with your ears I mean it's kind of silly perhaps to shut your eyes when you're looking at television But do it just for a moment and you will realize that The sounds you are hearing Are all coming out of silence you hear? And it fades away fades fades fades fades and finally disappears It's a curious world this isn't it because you hear all the realities in it the sounds suddenly coming out of nothing

00:13:39
You don't see any reason for them to begin they just appear and then they echo away Through the corridors of the mind which we call memory Now if you open your eyes It's a little harder to see this with your eyes because unlike sounds the eyes sound static Or rather, they look static everything looks still to your eyes, but you must understand that The world you are looking at say when you look at a light that light is vibrating all Material things are vibrations, and they are vibrating at you now in the same way as the sound was vibrating on your ears

00:14:30
In other words the present world that you see Is a vibration coming just as the sound comes out of silence the light is coming out of space It's coming out of nothing straight at you now and echoing away into the past So the course of time Is really very much like the course of a ship in the ocean? Because here's the ship you see and it leaves behind it awake And The wake fades out and that tells us where the ship has been In just the same way as the past and our memory of the past Tells us what we have done

00:15:29
But as we go back into the past and we go back and back to prehistory and we use all Kinds of instruments and scientific methods for detecting what happened we eventually reach a point Where all record of the past fades away in just the same way as the wake of the ship? Now the important thing to remember in this illustration is that the wake doesn't drive the ship Any more than the tail wags the dog? Especially there's a neurotic difficult child and The one school of thought used to say well bang him about beat him up and maybe he'll change

00:16:14
But then they said oh, no, it's not fair to the child to beat him up because it was his parents They didn't bring him up properly and so then they say well punish the parents well the parents say excuse me But I'm our parents when Urata - and they brought us up badly So we couldn't help what we did and so since the grandparents are dead We can't get at them and in any case supposing We could we would pass the whole blame back to Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden And they'd say they started all this mess, but then Eve

00:16:42
Would say no yeah the serpent tempted me, and I did eat, and it was the Serpent's fault Well, you know When God in the story of Genesis asked Eve? Didst thou eat the fruit of the tree. We're off. I told thee thou should not eat She said old with the serpent tempted me and I did eat And God looked at the serpent, and the serpent didn't make any excuse he probably winked Because The serpent being an angel was wise enough to know where the present begins So you see if you insist on? being

00:17:25
moved being determined by the past That's your game But the fact of the matter is it all starts right now But we like to establish Our connectivity with the past Because that Gives other people the impression that we're saying If you ask me then why am I talking? Well, I could say I'm making a living this way or I have a message that I want to get across to you But that's not the reason I'm talking for the same reason that birds sing and for the same reason that the stars shine

00:18:04
Is I I dig it why do you dig it? Well I could go on answering all sorts of questions about human motivation and psychology, but they wouldn't explain a thing because Explaining things by the past is really a refusal to explain them at all All you're doing is postponing the explanation you're putting it back and back and back and back and that explains nothing What does explain things is the present Why do you do it now Now This is a slight cheat because that doesn't explain it either

00:18:46
Because what happens now just as the sound comes out of silence all this comes out of nowhere this is In connection with what I explained to you in another talk about the power of nothingness all life suddenly emerges out of space bang right now and Who asked again why does it happen? Is an unprofitable question because the interesting thing is not why but what? What happens not why does it happen I? Can say well I am doing this now because I did that then and So I am producing for you a continuous line of thought

00:19:31
But actually I'm doing it backwards. I'm Doing it always from now and connecting up what I do now with what I did so that you couldn't conceive a consistent story If I define myself as the whole field of events we'll say the organism environment field which is the real me then all the things that happen to me may be called my doing and That is the real sense of karma But when we speak about Freedom from karma freedom from being the puppet of the past that simply involves a change in your thinking

00:20:10
It involves in other words You are getting rid of the habit of thought whereby you define yourself as the result of what has gone before and instead get into the more plausible and more reasonable habit of thought in terms of which you don't define yourself in terms of what you've done before but in terms of what you're doing now and That is liberation from the ridiculous situation of being a dog wagged by its tail Tonight I want to tell you three fantasies all of which have something in common

00:21:02
The first fantasy about is about reproduction We use the word reproduction in two principal ways when we talk about the biological reproduction of the species and When we talk about making a good reproduction of something in terms of a painting? the photograph or a recording or a videotape And what is all this about reproduction in that direction Hundreds of years ago kings of Europe Who wanted to? form feudal alliances by marrying the princesses of far-off States Would have painters send portraits of the lady in question

00:21:50
to see if his Majesty approved of her before he got her and There's a famous story in which Henry the eighth of England was badly cheated in this respect by a too flattering portrait of Anne of Cleves and Their father grew up a kind of morale among artists in the European tradition To make faithful reproductions of people and they perfected their technique beginning with the marvelous work of the Renaissance painters and the Flemish painters and going on finally to what Was called art officiel in the 19th century. We got what we now call

00:22:30
photographic realism But then they said Isn't the some more scientific way of doing this and so they discovered the camera And first of all the way you know remember those brownish Daguerreotype and people said well that is pretty it really looks like grandpa doesn't it And then they said but some things are several things missing it isn't colored So first of all they tinted them And then they said oh, it's real life-like But then they went on to say but you know there are some people whose whole style of life whose personality is in the way they move and

00:23:16
If you just take a static shot like that The personality isn't there it's away. They go, so they said we gotta have some way of making people move So they invented the movies and I remember when the first movies came out they were all going Everybody was getting you know in a jerky way then they smoothed it out, and they said ah that's real life like But they said then, but here's another thing about reproducing people which is that? They talk and a whole lot of their personality is in the voice

00:23:57
So can't we have them talking at the same time that they move? So they invented the talkies and Then to get it more lifelike still they colored them they said Wow now we're really getting somewhere Then To make it even more real they put it in 3d And you had to wear sort of spectacles over your face to see it that way But then they went on to say why is it that every time we want to see one of these things we have to go down to the center of town can't we have it all at home and so television came on and

00:24:39
In television they first of all started out with black and white and it was kind of Like Robert Benchley once described the cuts in French newspapers as all looking as if they had been made on bread Well that was television in a certain period and then they improved it and then they colored it and that's where we are now not quite because somebody has come out with the thing that we shall all be seeing soon, which is the hologram a television image produced by laser beams Where you see a? three-dimensional figure

00:25:14
out in the air in front of you I Say isn't that marvelous And then but of course when you go up to it, and you put your hand on it your hand goes right through it You can't touch it, and you see that was always the trouble with television Because you look at whatever you're seeing behind the screen it's intangible it doesn't smell and It won't relate to you So these are further problems to be solved in the techniques of Electronic reproduction, and they'll do it They are first of all managed a way in which

00:25:57
the electronic emission sources can solidify and make the air vibrate So that you go up, and you'll touch the figure and you won't be able to push your hand through it Because the air will be going faster than your hand Imagine that You could actually if was a beautiful dancer on the television you'll be able to go up and embrace her But she won't know you're there And she won't respond to you, and you'll say well. That's not very lifelike Just as they once said yeah, if the photograph doesn't move it's not very lifelike if it doesn't talk. It's not very lifelike

00:26:37
They'll next say if the reproduction in three dimensions solid doesn't respond. It's not very lifelike So they'll have to figure out a technique for doing that What will they do well I tell you? Sitting in your home Where you're watching the scene on a kind of stage now not on a screen? there will be a TV camera observing you and That TV camera will report back everything you do into a computer and the computer Will so manage each bit of information that's to say each tiny little

00:27:16
granule unit of information going into the image that you're looking at that it will Immediately decide what is the appropriate response to the approach that you are making to the image? Won't that be crazy? You know She may slap you in the face, and she may kiss you you never know but Then they say now this is still not really the kind of reproduction we wanted What we wanted when we looked at this scene is to be able to identify with one of the characters We wanted to not just watch the drama that's being performed on the stage in front of us, but actually get into it and

00:27:59
So we want to be wired in with a electro electrodes on the brain so that we will actually feel the emotions of the people acting on the stage and so Eventually we will get absolutely perfect reproduction and we will be able to See that image so vividly that we shall become And so the question arises Could that be where we are already Are we a reproduction Which over the centuries of evolution? Has worked out to be a replica of something else that was going on and we are where we always were Now the next fantasy concerns

00:28:56
The idea that every living being thinks it's human And that means a plant a worm a Virus a bacterium a fruit fly a hippopotamus a giraffe a rabbit That all these beings wherever they Feel out from as we feel out from our bodies Feel that they're in the middle that Is to say wherever you look you turn your head around and You feel you're in the middle of the world you feel you're at you're the center and a rabbit or a fruit fly feels that it is a center and it has around it a company of associates who look like it and

00:29:47
therefore this creature knows That these are the right people just as we know when we look at human beings They're the right people they are one of us Only of course we have to make distinctions Because you never really know that You are you and yet You are really in the right place unless you can contrast yourself with some other people who are after all not quite in the right place and Some other people who are very much in the wrong places and then through having this succession of comparisons you know that you're okay

00:30:19
Well the insect has exactly the same arrangement. Well you say well insects and things like fishes They don't have a culture What do you mean fish is being civilized and not being entitled to consider themselves as humans? Well, let me put the argument from the fishes point of view who? Fishes say human beings are a mess Look what they do They they can't exist Without cluttering themselves and carrying around all kinds of things outside their bodies. They have to have houses and automobiles and books

00:30:57
books and records and Television and hi-fi equipment and stuff endless stuff, and they litter the earth with rubbish Think of a dolphin isn't it really a fish because of dolphins and mammals but a dolphins point of view towards the human race Dolphins spend most of their time playing they don't work because the grocery is right there in the ocean whatever they need and so a dolphin will catch up with a seagoing liner and it'll get on the wake of the liner and put its tail at an exact angle of 26 degrees and

00:31:35
In so doing the liner will carry the dolphin long The dolphin will make circles around the line it is for fun playing all its life in the water and We know that a dolphin's brain is as big if not bigger than ours that it's incredibly intelligent That it has a language which we can't decipher and the person who knows most about dolphins in the United States dr. John Lilly is a friend of mine, and he said he came to the conclusion that dolphins were too smart to tell us their language

00:32:10
So He abandoned this project he said he would no longer keep such a highly civilized being in the Concentration camp of a zoo and that it should go back to the ocean So the point is though that every not only dolphins But every organism that has any sensitivity in it whatsoever Considers itself to be the center of the universe Now it has its problems There's a Zen poem which says The Morning Glory which blooms for an hour differs not at heart from a giant pine that lives for a thousand years

00:32:54
In other words an hour is a long life to a Morning Glory a Thousand years is the long life to a pint and our four score years and ten or as the Insurance companies actuarial tables put it somewhere between 65 and 70 years as an average human life Seems about the right length of life. I mean there are people who want to go on and on and our inquest of immortality and have their Bodies frozen in case there should develop in the future some technique by which they could be revived But I I really don't go for that idea

00:33:38
because Nature has mercifully arranged the principle of forgettery as well as the principle of memory If you always and always and always remembered everything you see you would be like a piece of paper Which had been painted over and painted over and painted over until there was no space left And you wouldn't be able to distinguish between one thing in another Is that when a whole bunch of people start to scream and make noises and out scream each other and soon you can hear nobody? So in that way one's memories become screams and

00:34:17
Nature mercifully arranges that the whole thing be erased And you begin again does he doesn't matter in what form you begin? Whether you begin again as a human being or? as the fruit fly a butterfly or a beetle or a bird It feels the same way that you feel now So we're really all in the same place, and we all have above us Things much higher than ourselves and We all have below us things that we feel are much lower than ourselves Just as there are things out there on the left and things out there on the right and things in front and things behind

00:34:59
Because you're the middle you're the middle everywhere always Now my third fantasy Nobody has it seems to me really seriously ask the question. How do stars begin? Why how out of space do these enormous radioactive centers arise Well I'm going to solve this problem on the principle of the egg and the hen Because it is said a chicken is one eggs way of becoming other eggs And If you've understood my second fantasy you will see how that could be true Now let's suppose then that a planet

00:35:59
Is one Stars way of becoming another star? You know stars when they explode They send a lot of goo out into space and some of this goo solidifies into balls which get in orbit and spin round the star and in one chance in a thousand maybe one of those balls will become like the planet Earth and Slowly upon it will arise What some people might call a disease called the bacteria of intelligent life? and they Haven't notion these things that if we call alive that they ought to go on There you know they have a fixed idea in their heads

00:36:45
That they should keep on doing whatever it is. They're doing and they should always be doing it better So they divide themselves into different species and these species compete with each other in order to As it will flex their muscles and get better and better at whatever it is. They are and They go on doing this until one species really establishes itself as top species in the particular area on the particular planet as we Human beings Homo sapiens have established our selves as top species on earth

00:37:20
Whatever top means Well, then when we have a little leisure and don't have to spend all our time Finding food to put into our mouths We start asking questions, and we look around at each other and everything and say what is this I? Mean what's going on here Well some people say that's a stupid question to ask Why don't you just go on doing your work? Go hunting go farming go doing your business? They say no there are higher things So they create a special class of people who are in India called Brahmans among?

00:37:56
us philosophers scientists theologians Thinkers and they go into this question, and they are allowed to Stop farming to stop hunting to stop mining to stop scrubbing floors and to go to very special places called Universities where they can sit around and think about what is going on oh? They think about this first of all they do what they call philosophy Which is they try to say? What it means with it, what is the word be what is the word exists me, what do we mean when we say we're here or they find they can't discuss that very far because

00:38:46
The word stops meaning anything it sort of becomes the noise the sin and we're not really getting to the point what we've got to do is instead of thinking all the time and just Theorizing and talking words about what's going on. We've got to investigate it experimentally We've somehow got to look into this stuff that we call Reality the material world and find out what it is So they start chopping it up. See they go into flowers, and they chop up the seeds And they look into the middle of the scenes they find something there

00:39:18
I'm gonna have to get a magnifying glass and looking on that It gets smaller and smaller and smaller and they three reason they must eventually come to some particle called an akan in Greek autumn means our Thomas nan cuttable What you can't split any further? So they come down to the I promise That then which there is no, which er they thought But then they found they could split that atom they could find the electron the positron the mason etc etc etc forever And so they said well, this is I mean, this is a real science because we've now found out

00:40:04
that every optimist of matter contains Immense energy and that we could come to the point where We could release the energy in the atom and the trouble with intellectual people is that anything that can be done must be done and So eventually in the necessary course of the development of nature They found out how to blow the earth to pieces and turn it into a star So that Maybe you see how stars originate they have planets like chickens have eggs and the eggs burst and turn into chickens and Planets burst through the agency of intelligent life and turn into stars which throw out other mud balls

00:41:01
Which some of which stand a reasonable chance about as reasonable a chance to say any male? spermatozoon Stands when it enters the female womb of becoming a baby one in a million and those spermatozoa are in exactly the same position as The planets and the stars now I tell you this is a fantasy, but you may ask me isn't it a rather unpleasant fantasy Aren't things going the wrong way the wrong direction in other words if The whole point of life I mean this tender biological Substance with all its tubes and filaments and nerves which is so very sensitive if all this is to end up in fire

00:41:54
into an absolute blaze of light Don't we say oh what a shame you don't is that the way it ends But so many people say that they want to see the light They want to be enlightened. They want to dissolve into the light of God Then when they've done that all over again the process goes on it blows out those mud balls and Here are planets and here once again You're a baby. You're a child The flowers are brilliantly colored The Stars are gorgeous the smell of the earth the sound of the rain

00:42:52
Everything is marvelous once again and once again you see The other The man the woman that you love As if it had never happened before it all starts over And as it goes on it gets more and more intense all the problems get more and more problematic And you find you're wrestling with something you can't control You've got to control it but you absolutely Can't control it like all the problems of the world at the present time is the the whole scene is completely out of hand And we feel we're going to our doom

00:43:34
Because we are going once again towards the birth of a star, which is the most creative thing there is Now if you think about this for a while you see well put forward three fantasies all of which have a cyclic quality We reproduce not only biologically But we reproduce artistically technically So just for a moment I want to put in an aside about biological Er. Now think back To my grandfather whom I knew fairly well He was when I was a little boy, he was something extraordinarily impressive He looked like King Edward the seventh he was a very very elegant man

00:44:34
Because a little goatee beard he didn't have sideburns like this, and he had shorter hair But he was very elegant fellow dress beautifully, and I thought you know he was the very image of God And now here I am The same age as he was when I first knew him and I have five grandchildren and I'm No longer impressed by grandfathers I'm one of them, too And this is the same idea you see of the round That we are Almost Perpetually in the same place as the French proverb says blue Sash in Irish blue still our name shows the more it changes. The more it's the same thing

00:45:33
Well That means then you see that Existence the feeling of being is a sort of spectrum just as light is at one end red and at the other end violet and You have to have these extremes in order to have color at all in order to know light so you see likewise we we have to Have the experience that there is somebody else Something else going on altogether out of our control in order to have the experience of being me and So in order to feel good to feel that My life is worthwhile at existences is worth going on with

00:46:29
In order to bring out that feeling just as the red brings out the violet There has to be in the back of our minds Maybe very far away the comprehension that there is something that could happen that absolutely mustn't happen There is the horrors that is the screaming me means at the end of the line We have to know that's there and every so often that has to happen because if there isn't The experience that we go through called the Screaming Mimi's at the end of the line Where everything has gone wrong?

00:47:03
Like just before he died the British novelist Arnold Bennett said I feel somehow that everything is absolutely wrong You know So the the the the possibility even the the imagination that there could be such an experience in the back of our heads is the background Which gives intensity to the sense that we call feeling good feeling that it's it's all right? It's all right So If you understand that You see that really and truly you're always in the same place just as every creature thinks it's a human being

00:47:51
and It's just every being turns out to be a reproduction By some interesting technology whether it's electronic or biological makes very little difference and Just as it may be I don't know Planets are stars ways of becoming other stars and so on and so on and so on but the moral is You're always in the same place And what is that place? You can ask yourself very very I won't say seriously because this isn't really serious it's sincere Ask yourself very sincerely if that is so

00:48:38
if in other words The place in which you are now is the place where? Everything and everybody else really is only there's an arrangement to pretend that you ought to be somewhere else So the place where you are is the place where you're always pretending you ought to be somewhere else and This is the nature of life. This is the pulse I? Ought to be somewhere else So it's a kind of an orgasm like that see when if you discover that that's the trick that you're playing on yourself

00:49:18
You become serene and you Don't entirely give up the game because that you've seen through it, but you say hmm it really might be fun to go on playing